The Best Pizzelle Maker To Make A Homemade Italian Classic

best pizzelle maker

Sweets are always a treat to eat. It is hard to resist a delectably sweet snack once it is in front of you, of course, unless you are a master of being able to resist the temptation. However, for most people, nostalgic snacks & treat will always have a place in their hearts.

More...

A pizzelle is a cookie that many know what it is by just looking at it. For those who grew up in Italy, pizzelles are a big part of their childhood. Thus, many go in search for the best pizzelle maker to use in their homes.

Although there are many Italians who want to find a great pizzelle maker to use, it isn’t exclusive to only them, as many people enjoy the crispy snack as well.

Rank

Image

Product Name

Our Rating

Price

best pizzelle maker

Cucina Pro Non-Stick Pizzelle Maker

2

best pizzelle maker

Chef’s Choice 834 Pizzelle Pro Express Bake

3

best pizzelle maker

Cuisinart WM-PZ2 Pizzelle Press

4

best pizzelle maker

Piccolo Pizzelle Baker by Cucina Pro

5

best pizzelle maker

Chef’s Choice 835 Pizzelle Pro Express Bake

What Are Pizelles?

Pizelles are a traditional Italian snack and are thin, crispy or chewy waffle cookies. The cookie is from Ortona, the Abruzzo region of central Italy, and it is popular during Christmas and Easter. Its name comes from the Italian word for flat or round. The cookie’s name may sound very similar to pizza, but that’s because it means the same thing in Italian.

best pizzelle maker

People make the cookie from eggs, sugar, flour, butter/vegetable oil, and flavorings. There aren’t any restriction placed on what kind of flavor you want your cookie to come in, but the most common option is anise. It is less common to find pizzelles with lemon zest or vanilla flavors. However, what does manage to remain the same is its design and shapes.

The pizzelle come in various flat and circular geometric designs. These designs do not only make the cookie look attractive to eat but also make the cookie crispy as well. The cookie sizes, on the other hand, can range from 3 inches in diameter to as big as 5 inches.

It is eaten it its flat form, but some people prefer to roll it or make it into cones while it is still warm. This is to make space for ice cream, sauces, and more sweet things. It is common for two pizzelle to be sandwiched with cannoli cream ( ricotta cheese blended with sugar) or hazelnut spread. The rolled up pizzelle become cannoli shells and filled with crèmes.

The cookie dough or batter gets placed into a pizzelle press or iron. It is very similar to the way a waffle iron is made but can cook from two to three cookies at the same time. The traditional iron is held by hand over a hot burner on the stovetop. The more recent models are electric and only require to be plugged in.

How To Choose A Pizzelle Maker

Hopefully, I’ve made you hungry enough to want to start making your pizzelle. The next step is choosing a unit that will suit your cooking skills. The traditional method of using a pizzelle press over a stove may be the more legitimate way of cooking, but electric options do the job just as well. It is now a matter of choosing what surface you want to work on.

best pizzelle maker

There are two surfaces for pizzelle: the non-stick surface and the cast aluminum surface. There isn’t a preferred surface for making the cookie because both surfaces get the job done. There are other important things to remember when it comes to picking out a pizzelle maker.

1. Easy To Clean

You’ll be busy making cookies over and over again, so having a press that is easy to clean is a no-brainer. There are some presses that don’t do this well, and it results in burnt, uneven, and destroyed pizzelles. If the pizzelles don’t get out of the molds easily, that can only mean that cleaning won’t be easy either.

When it comes to non-stick surfaces, it is relatively easy to clean. However, there are some non-stick surfaces that are too thin, or the coating isn’t of great quality. So reading reviews help when determining how well a non-stick surface will fare.Aluminum cast presses, on the other hand, will be easy to clean as long as it’s been properly greased before cooking.

2. Evenly Heated

Making thin cookies require one very important element: even heat. The problem is that there are some presses that don’t distribute heat properly. This makes the cookies unevenly cooked, and burnt at some point. Not only does this waste a lot of the dough or batter, but it also gets frustrating to continue cooking.

As long as the unit can distribute heat evenly, the cookies will not only look great, but you will be able to cook more in no time flat.

3. Sturdy Handles and Locks

Heavy duty presses should have sturdy handles and locks. This is to make sure the batter stays in place and that the press doesn’t suddenly break as you pry out a cookie.

Low-quality presses won’t have this problem right away, but with prolonged use, it will start deteriorating and will break at some point. Make sure you get a quality press to save money and cut the stress.

4. Cookie Design

The floral and snowflake design shouldn’t be what concerns you; it is actually how deep the grooves are. Sometimes the batter overflows and creates uneven cookies, which isn’t a pretty sight at all. The best option is to check if the grooves are deep enough to hold the batter while pressed. Checking reviews help a lot as well.

There are a lot of products out in the market that claims they can make pizzelles just like old days. However, only a handful have the vote of consumers around the world.

Top 5 Best Pizzelle Maker On The Market

Rank

Image

Product Name

Our Rating

Price

best pizzelle maker

Cucina Pro Non-Stick Pizzelle Maker

2

best pizzelle maker

Chef’s Choice 834 Pizzelle Pro Express Bake

3

best pizzelle maker

Cuisinart WM-PZ2 Pizzelle Press

4

best pizzelle maker

Piccolo Pizzelle Baker by Cucina Pro

5

best pizzelle maker

Chef’s Choice 835 Pizzelle Pro Express Bake

Here are the top five highly reviewed pizzelle makers that you can check out:

1. Cucina Pro Non-Stick Pizzelle Maker

This particular pizzelle maker makes the standard two cookies at the same time, and they measure 5-inches. According to the product description, it has a steam guard to protect hands, extra-thick baking plates for even heat distribution, and easy clean up as well. At a glance, this at-home cooking machine looks professional and sturdy.

A lot of reviews have praised the Cucina Pro for having evenly heated plates. It also lives up to its product description of having easy cleanup and easy usage as well. Unfortunately, there isn’t a built-in timer, and the unit gets hotter with prolonged cooking use. However, given the affordable price range, it is a steal.

What We Like

  • Heats up and cooks evenly
  • Easy to use
  • Easy to clean up
  • Consistent heat
  • Has a lock

What We Don't Like

  • No built in timer
  • Heat gets hotter with longer use

2. Chef’s Choice 834 Pizzelle Pro Express Bake

The Chef’s Choice Pizzelle Maker has a standard two cookie plate that claims to bake in less than thirty seconds. For many chefs and business owners, this is good to have as the more cookies mean more sales. The product description further claims that the heat is consistent, has a non-stick baking surface, and even has recipe’s included.

The two four 3/4-inch pizzelles are a good size for cones and cannolis. Many users were pleased with the thin cookies, but some have complained that it is too thin to their liking. Other disappointments in the unit are easily broken plastic latches, it gets very hot on the outside, and there is no temperature adjustment or timer.

It isn’t completely useless as its design is very modern, and the plates to heat evenly. It is also easy to use and easy to clean, which is a basic for non-stick appliances. However, a lot of people aren’t happy with the problems they encountered while using the product, even with a 1-year warranty.

What We Like

  • Easy To Use
  • Easy to clean
  • Nice design
  • Heats evenly

What We Don't Like

  • Plastic latch breaks
  • Gets hot on the outside
  • Some cookies are too thin
  • Can’t adjust temperature
  • No timer

3. Cuisinart WM-PZ2 Pizzelle Press

The Cuisinart is another unit that bakes two cookies at the same time. Just like many other pizzelle makers, the pizzelle grooves have two decorative patterns imprinted on it. According to the product description, it is made out of stainless steel, has a dual light indicator, and you can choose how brown you want your cookies.

Reviews have praised this press for being convenient, easy to operate, and having smaller sized cookies. Although it may take some time to get used to using it, many have no complaints on how well it bakes cookies. Plus it also comes with a measuring spoon and instructions to round out the entire set.

Unfortunately, this appliance doesn’t come with a timer, has useless instructions, and isn’t stable enough overall. It also overheats and poses as a danger especially when kids are around. Given the expensive price tag, many don’t see it as a useful buy.

What We Like

  • Metal plates are small
  • Easy to operate
  • Convenient
  • Takes some time getting used to it
  • Comes with a measuring spoon
  • Easy cleanup

What We Don't Like

  • No timer
  • Useless instructions
  • Not stable regarding build and design
  • Overheats

4. Piccolo Pizzelle Baker by Cucina Pro

This pizzelle maker has the smallest sized pizzelles by far, and it also makes up to 4 mini cookies at 3.25 inches in diameter. The product description claims easy heat distribution, non-stick grids for easy baking and cleaning.

The best part of this unit is that it makes four cookies at the same time and that it has a non-stick surface. Unfortunately, there are a lot of cons that make this unit hard to use. First of all, the pizzelle design has shallow cookie edges which make the dough run over. This makes ugly edges, but it can be remedied by using a knife to cut away the excess.

The second major issue is that the heating is off and uneven. This is a big negative as the product claims to have even heating. So this makes the cookies uneven. Plus, it is too thin, which is a contributing factor to the uneven browning of the cookies.

Lastly, the unit breaks after a month. There was even one user who bought the product twice but and broke it twice as well. What broke were the handles and the lock that kept the press shut during baking. Although the price range is reasonable, and there are some good reviews, some stated that it is more of a gamble to use the product for long periods of time.

What We Like

  • Four cookies per batch
  • Non-stick surface

What We Don't Like

  • Shallow cookie edges, the dough runs over
  • Heating is uneven
  • Cookies are made too thin
  • Breaks easily

5. Chef’s Choice 835 Pizzelle Pro Express Bake

The Chef’s Choice Pro-Express bake makes smaller pizzelles and three at a time. This makes one 3-inch diameter cookie at a time. According to the product description, the unit comes with non-stick plates, stores upright, has electronic controls and can be baked in 45-60 seconds flat. As compared to other cookies, this is perfect for parties thanks to its bigger size.

Just like the other Chef’s Choice unit, it is easy to use, heats up fast, and is easy to store. A big plus to this particular model is that it is temperature controlled, which is something the other brands don’t have. However, it only makes one pizzelle at a time, which makes it time-consuming to make in bulk.

Also, the unit itself isn’t very sturdy either. There are instances where the lock and handle breaks within a six month period. Apart from this, the metal gets hot while cooking and can pose as a hazard to those who have kids in the household. Although it may be the cheapest unit, there are a lot of cons to it as well.

What We Like

  • Easy To Use
  • Heats Up Fast
  • Larger Pizzelle size
  • Easy to clean; easy storage
  • Temperature controlled

What We Don't Like

  • Lock breaks
  • Handle broke after six months
  • Metal gets hot while cooking

Our Best Pizzelle Maker Pick

These five products are already the cream of the crop when it comes to making that perfect homemade pizzelle. Given all the feedback, it is safe to say that the Cuisina Pro is the best pizzelle maker. Not only does it look sturdy and professional, but it also works like a charm. Plus is doesn’t have as many issues that the other options had.

I do hope that this article was of some help to you on your mission to find the best pizzelle maker around. If you have made pizzelle before, I’d love to read your comments on it in the comments section below. Also, if you have any interesting pizzelle recipes to share, do share them as well!

Charlotte Lane

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Comment: